Review Process

Here is the accurate English translation, maintaining the exact template structure, numbering, bullet points, and wording as closely as possible while using natural, scholarly English:

  1. After the author submits the article, the article will undergo a plagiarism check using Turnitin by the editorial team.
  2. Articles that pass the plagiarism check will then undergo review by the editorial team, considering the focus and scope, level of novelty, significance of the article, accuracy of content, originality, and clarity of description.
  3. The article then proceeds to the peer review process conducted openly (open).
  4. In conducting the review, the reviewer considers: novelty of the topic, objectivity, methodology, scientific impact/implications, conclusions, and references. The reviewer selects one of the final recommendations as follows:
  • Accept Submission. Accepting the article without any revisions required.
  • Revision Required. Requiring revisions without the need for re-review. After the author revises the manuscript, it proceeds directly to the editing process.
  • Resubmit for Review. Requiring revisions, and after the author revises the manuscript, it will be reviewed again.
  • Resubmit elsewhere: The manuscript is rejected and recommended for submission to another journal.
  • Decline Submission. Rejecting the manuscript because the quality does not meet the requirements.
  • See comments: Revisions are required in accordance with the reviewer's suggestions (in the form of recommendations).